GoHotelly
2-star hotel Check-in 15:00 · Check-out 11:00

Mountain Creek Tavern

Stay at Mountain Creek Tavern in Mt Holly Springs, PA. Rated 4.7 with 23 reviews, close to Pine Grove Furnace State Park and Appalachian Trail Museum.

31 S Baltimore Ave, Mt Holly Springs, PA 17065, United States View on map
9.4/10
Exceptional Based on 23 recent guest reviews
What recent guests emphasize

Mountain Creek Tavern guest insights

Recent visitors highlight the property's cozy comfort, attentive service, and convenient location for outdoor activities, with a few notes on room features and check-in style.

Guests often praise

  • Complimentary snacks, coffee, and bottled water provided in rooms.
  • Clean, freshly updated rooms with comfortable beds and new linens.
  • Helpful and friendly staff offering attentive customer service.
  • Convenient in-room amenities including a mini fridge, microwave, and coffee maker.
  • Beautiful, quiet location near nature and popular outdoor attractions.

Worth knowing

  • Check-in is contactless and phone-based with no 24/7 front desk presence, which may require a brief phone call for access.
  • Some rooms have thin walls that may allow noise to carry between units.
  • There was a minor issue reported with one shower head causing water to leak onto the floor.
  • The Tavern may occasionally be closed for renovations or seasonal updates, so checking availability is recommended.

Best for

  • Nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts visiting nearby state parks and hiking trails.
  • Travelers seeking a quiet, affordable stopover with basic comforts and modern touches.
  • Families and small groups looking for convenient amenities like a microwave and fridge in-room.
  • Visitors who appreciate hassle-free, contactless check-in combined with personal goodwill from staff.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Mountain Creek Tavern

Mountain Creek Tavern is a modestly renovated hotel located in Mt Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, offering a quiet and natural setting near the mountain creek it is named after. Guests appreciate its clean and comfortable rooms, which come equipped with conveniences such as a microwave, mini fridge, coffee maker, and complimentary snacks and bottled water. Check-in is contactless and typically managed by phone, with friendly staff available to assist remotely.

The property benefits from a convenient location on South Baltimore Avenue, close to several outdoor attractions including Pine Grove Furnace State Park, Kings Gap Environmental Education Center, and the Appalachian Trail Museum. These destinations offer extensive hiking opportunities, educational exhibits, and scenic views, making the tavern a practical base for travelers interested in nature and recreation.

Nearby amenities include an on-site ATM, while airport access is relatively straightforward, with Harrisburg International Airport reachable in under an hour by car. Several other hotels and bed and breakfasts are within a short drive, though Mountain Creek Tavern stands out for its personable service and a quiet, easygoing atmosphere appreciated by guests passing through or staying for longer periods.

Reviewers have noted the hotel’s overall cleanliness and the helpfulness of staff, although some mention the thin walls and occasional room maintenance quirks. These factors suggest the property suits travelers who prioritize location, modest comfort, and a low-key experience over luxury. It is especially recommended for visitors who value nature-based activities and require practical accommodations in the Mt Holly Springs area.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

AL
Andreas Lenz Mar 24, 2026
10

Check-in by phone was as easy as described in the reservation. Little snacks, coffee and complimentary water were offered in the rooms. It is the ideal place to stay for a night on your way through or you can enjoy nature. Don't miss Gettysburg and take a look at one of the most historic sites in the U.S.

FC
Francisco Cotte Mar 22, 2026
10

EDIT on bottom--This place was absolutely beautiful. The rooms looked clean and freshly remodeled. We stayed here, in room 5, for 4 nights over thanksgiving. The check in process was pretty cool. We called and the lady was really nice. Brie sent us the code. for our room key. Brei also called and made sure we were good. The hospitality was great. The view was amazing. cute little snack basket, mini fridge, microwave and coffee pot with coffee. Only one issue, nothing that would stop us from coming here again. 1) The shower head squirted water, near the threads, towards the side wall. Causing water to run down and flood the floor. We put a hand towel over it to direct it down. With all that said, we will be back. I will fully recommend this place. EDIT: We got home Sunday evening. Brei called my wife to let us know that our 4 year old left her Care Bear. She is going to mail it out to us. Which is beyond awesome. This place just moved to the top of our "must stay again" list.

DB
Dave Bevis Feb 28, 2026
10

Great little motel. Owner was super friendly and helpful. Room was spotless, well equipped as well, fridge , microwave, coffee and a gift basket! MABDR friendly.

JR
Jon R Feb 27, 2026
10

Needed a last minute hotel and the price was great. Checking in took a second just because there isn't someone there every minute of the day. A quick phone call and I was in my room. The room was nice and clean. Just a word of warning the walls are thin. The owner is supper nice! Would recommend.

MW
Melissa Waugh Feb 16, 2026
10

A great little motel. Quiet, easy to find, and safe. We stayed here years ago, and the recent updates don't disappoint, fluffy new towels, new bedding, comfortable new beds, microwave, refrigerator, coffee maker, snacks. The staff went above and beyond to make our stay great.

JN
Joseph Neumann Jan 12, 2026
10

A fishing buddy and I came to the area to fly fish the famed limestone spring creeks Yellow Breeches, Letort Spring run and Big Creek Spring. Mountain Creek Tavern was the perfect location for a base camp. The room looked and smelled noticeably clean, the bathtub was newer, there was a nice coffee service and a selection of complimentary snacks. The furniture is what you'd expect from a mid-century motel, but the beds were very comfortable and that's the most important. Although check-in is contactless, a manger was there to greet us and make sure the room was in order before our arrival and that we had plenty of coffee. Great customer service. There were restaurants all around town and a good one right across the street. We were just sorry that the Tavern was closed for renovation, but we're hoping it will be open for our next visit, because we will be back.

EO
Erin Owens Dec 27, 2025
10

I stayed here this past weekend for my 13 year old daughter’s soccer tournament. We had a great experience and the off site staff were helpful and ensured we got into our room. It was safe, clean, and in a beautiful location. The girls loved the snack basket I would stay here again.

AJ
Abigail Johnson Dec 25, 2025
10

Complimentary snacks, coffee, and water in the room, plus a fridge and a microwave! It is located right in front of the beautiful mountain creek. Misti helped us get checked in and she was so nice. Nice, cute, and affordable place to stay for the weekend.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Mountain Creek Tavern

Mt Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Harrisburg International Airport 43 min Car
  • State College Regional Airport 2 hr 1 Car
  • Lancaster Airport 1 hr 14 Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Pennsylvania. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Pine Grove Furnace State Park 2,406 reviews

Pine Grove Furnace State Park

1100 Pine Grove Rd, Gardners, PA 17324, United States

4.7 · State Park
Kings Gap Environmental Education Center 329 reviews

Kings Gap Environmental Education Center

500 Kings Gap Rd, Carlisle, PA 17015, United States

4.8 · State Park
Appalachian Trail Museum 176 reviews

Appalachian Trail Museum

1120 Pine Grove Rd, Gardners, PA 17324, United States

4.8 · Museum
People also viewed

Similar Hotels in Pennsylvania

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

340 Greentree Dr, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, United States

Super 8 by Wyndham East Stroudsburg/Poconos

3.9star hotel offering free WiFi, breakfast & parking near Crossings Premium Outlets and Shawnee Mountain. Familyfriendly stay ...

3.9 (606) View
1108 60th St, Brooklyn, NY 11219, United States

Umbrella Hotel Brooklyn

Modest 3.3rated hotel in Brooklyn offering free WiFi, parking, and airconditioned rooms. Near Statue of Liberty, Brooklyn Museu...

3.3 (312) View
1770 US-45 BYP, Jackson, TN 38305, United States

DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Jackson

Modern hotel with free WiFi, indoor/outdoor pool, and Southern restaurant. Rated 3.9 from 1,435 reviews, near Union University an...

3.9 (1,435) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Mountain Creek Tavern? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.